CHAPTER 25
Death of an Understanding
![]() |
| © 2026 • Photo by Richard Zampella at The Winter Garden Theater 4.9.26 |
I left Idylease this morning alone, driving toward the city with more on my mind than I realized. Gravel lifted under the spinning tires as the truck moved onto the pavement. As I passed the main building, I glanced left and watched the trees I had planted as a boy move past the windows, each mile toward New York carrying the weight of memory.
On that drive, I knew I would think of my father—his hands steady, his attention fixed on what was in front of him, lessons given without being spoken. I thought of the production of Death of a Salesman we had seen together at the Broadhurst Theater in 1984.
Over the course of my life, I had seen it three times—at sixteen, at thirty-five, and now again: Dustin Hoffman, Brian Dennehy, Nathan Lane. Each time I believed I understood it. I began thinking that maybe I had gotten it wrong.
Each performance marks a point in time, a line drawn between who you were then and who you have become.
By the time I arrived in the city, I knew I would be meeting John and Shannon at the theater, and John has steadied me for years in the way my father once did. There are lines in a life that extend beyond blood, continuing through time in other forms.
As I made my way there, every turn carried something with it—the film work I had done with John, the memory of my father, the accumulation of small acts of attention that had shaped the course of my life. All of it coexisted in that moment, pressing forward. There was a sense that something might be revealed over the course of the day that I did not yet understand.
When I arrived at Penn Station, I moved through the concourse with the same forward motion as everyone else. At the base of a column, I stopped. An advertisement wrapped around it read, “You’re only as strong as the place you came from.” I shook my head and kept moving.
I moved with the crowd toward the street and kept walking.
As I walked from Penn Station to Midtown, I began to recognize places I had thought I had forgotten and passed them without stopping.
When I arrived outside the theater, I did not get on line immediately. I crossed Broadway and looked back at the building facade, where a long billboard stretched across it:
Attention Must be Paid.
The words were set against a dark field. Little else competed. I stood there and took a photograph. As I lowered the camera, I noticed something else—a car positioned slightly behind the lettering. It did not dominate the image, but it was there.
It struck me as odd. I did not remember it as central to the play when I had seen it before. I looked at it a moment longer, then crossed back.
When I crossed back, I saw the line.
It wrapped around the block and folded in on itself as it turned the corner. People stood quietly, waiting; no one seemed impatient. There was a kind of order to it, and an anticipation.
This was not normal.
I took my place on line and stood waiting for John and Shannon. As I settled in, I noticed Alan Alda step in behind me. There was no announcement; no one turned. He stood there quietly, like everyone else.
The line began to move.
When they arrived, we spoke briefly and then stepped forward together. The doors opened and we passed through the lobby, where the sound changed and the street disappeared behind us. We entered from the rear of the theater, and that was when I first saw it—the set, already there and waiting.
As we moved down the aisle, I stared at it and did not look anywhere else. People were taking their seats around us, but I paid little attention to them or the usher who led us down the aisle. The movement of the theater continued but felt separate from what I was seeing.
It gave me an immediate, visceral response. There was something in the arrangement that felt familiar. I thought of Jersey City.
I kept looking as we moved closer. When we reached our seats in the front row—house seats held for guests of the producer—we were close enough that there was no separation, the stage directly in front of us.
Even before it began, the set had already begun to alter the space: two empty chairs at an empty table, everything arranged but not fixed. It was a structure without walls that did not feel like a home, less like a stage than something remembered.
There was a fog in the air, barely perceptible, but the theater lights caught it. The light shifted, as if it could change at any moment. There was a stillness to it.
There was still movement in the theater as people settled into their seats, but I remained fixed on the stage. Then the lights began to go down, not all at once but receding in stages until the theater dimmed and the faces around us disappeared into shadow.
What remained was the stage.
The set was the anchor, and the distance between where we sat and what we were looking at narrowed until there was no separation.
Then it began.
The sound came first—a low mechanical shift from behind the set. A garage door lifted, and then the car came out. I did not remember that; in all the times I had seen the play before, the car had only existed in reference.
Now it was there—physical—moving forward and settling into position as the headlights cut into the audience.
And it remained.
It stayed there.
Then the play began and I had two thoughts, the first coming quickly: I thought it would be as I remembered it, a story centered on a father and a son.
Then the actors began to move within the space, bringing me back to my years at Rutgers and the Meisner Technique.
I let go of whatever expectations I had carried with me, stopped trying to interpret it, and watched.
I was no longer in the theater.
I was inside it.
Something personal.
Then she delivered the line.
“Attention must be paid.”
It landed differently this time.
I thought of my father, and then of my mother.
I wished she had protected him.
My mother and I could not speak the truth to one another.
No one stepped in.
At intermission, I stepped to the apron of the stage and took a photograph. The house was full, and Shannon and John sat in the foreground just off to my left. There was a quiet in the theater, even then.
During the second act, sitting just a few feet from the stage, watching Nathan Lane as Willy Loman planted seeds, I was no longer observing a performance but inside it, close enough to see his makeup and hear him breathe as he worked the soil.
A witness.
Later in the act, she stood at his grave and spoke to him as if he were still there. She had carried it alone.
She said they were free.
“We’re free.”
When the play ended, the actors stood for their bows. There was a look on their faces, and in a few hours they would do it again—the same words, the same movements, the same weight.
And it would not be the same.
We exited the theater with the others and into the light.
After the curtain call, we stood on the street. I said to John and Shannon that the center of the play had shifted for me, and they listened as we stood there for a moment.
I wanted to stay.
I did not.
There was oil to pick up, the tank at Idylease running low.
I tried to explain it simply.
They understood, but not completely.
There was a pause between us.
Then I left them there on the sidewalk and walked toward the subway.
As I walked through Times Square and down the stairs to the train, the noise of the street began to fall away. The movement of people, the lights, the sound—all of it receded as I made my way toward the platform.
The subway cars pulled into the station.
“Watch the closing doors, please…”
I stepped inside and disappeared into the crowded train.
When I arrived back at Idylease, the grounds were quiet. The building loomed over me, the way it always did.
Waiting for me.
At times I had the sense it knew when I was gone, as if it recognized when my attention had shifted elsewhere.
I usually dismissed that thought.
But there are moments when it feels true.
Attention must be paid.
John and Shannon were still on the sidewalk when I left them.
It was decided long ago.
I carried the oil from the truck.
And I filled the tank.







